EyeHackDownload for Mac

Why you skip break reminders, and how to stop

Updated

TL;DR

  • You skip break reminders because ignoring one costs a single click and nothing visible happens when you do.
  • Two small 2023 studies disagree on whether 20-second breaks help eye strain, so the evidence is mixed.
  • In the study where reminders helped, the benefit faded within a week of stopping them, so a reminder you disable gives you nothing.
  • A break you cannot skip removes the daily decision, but it needs call detection and does not suit everyone.
  • EyeHack is a Mac menubar app with no skip and no snooze, $14.99 once with a 14-day free trial.

You skip break reminders because ignoring one takes a single click and nothing bad seems to happen. The two things that work are a reminder you cannot dismiss, or a habit strong enough that you no longer need one.

This is not medical advice. See an eye doctor if symptoms persist.

What happens when the reminder appears

A typical reminder is a small banner with "Skip" and "Snooze". It shows up while you are in the middle of a function, a sentence or a spreadsheet formula. Closing it takes under a second. Taking the break means dropping what you were holding in your head.

So you click Skip. It comes back in 5 minutes, and you click Snooze. After a week you stop reading the text.

Some apps add friction. LookAway limits skips and snoozes per session and per day. Stretchly allows one postpone per break. Both make skipping cost something, and both still leave a way out.

Do break reminders help?

Maybe. The research is mixed.

In one 2023 study, people who got 20-20-20 reminders for two weeks had fewer eye strain symptoms. The effect was gone a week after the reminders stopped. In another 2023 study, scheduled 20-second breaks made no significant difference to symptoms.

Breaks are cheap and low risk, so they are worth trying. For more on the disagreement, see the 20-20-20 research.

Why a skip button defeats the point

A break you can skip is a break you decide to take, every 20 minutes, while tired and busy. That is when your decisions are worst. People who say they "always" take breaks usually mean the first few days.

Removing the choice removes the daily argument with yourself. The screen is covered, you look away, and 20 seconds later you carry on.

A week with a reminder you can ignore

On day one you take every break. On day two a deadline lands and you snooze twice. By day four you hit Skip before the banner finishes appearing.

That is not a character flaw. The reminder asks for a decision at the worst moment, and each skip makes the next one easier.

The limits of a no-skip break

A forced break has real downsides.

  • You cannot finish a thought. Twenty seconds is short, but it can interrupt you mid-sentence.
  • It must not fire during a call. An app that covers your screen in a client meeting is worse than no app.
  • Some people need an override, for example during a live demo or a trading session. For them a skippable app is the better pick.

EyeHack waits while you're on a call (any app using your microphone or camera) and while a common screen recorder is running. See how that works in meetings.

If you want a skip button, the comparison of skip rules lists which apps allow what.

Other ways to make breaks stick

Any tool works better with these.

  • Attach the break to something that already happens, such as standing to refill water.
  • Pick a break that takes under a minute, so it never competes with real work.
  • Make the break pleasant. A reminder you look forward to is one you stop dismissing.

Desk eye exercises give you something to do with the 20 seconds.

What to look for in a reminder app

Look at how the app treats the skip itself.

  • Postpone limits. They cap how often you can postpone each day. You still choose every time until the cap hits.
  • A cooldown. Apps such as ForceBreak make you wait before the dismiss button appears. The button is still there.
  • No skip at all. The break runs its full length. This needs call detection.
  • Quiet defaults. An app that stays silent during calls and recordings gets left on, and an app you leave on works better than one you disable.

The list of break apps you cannot skip compares them with prices.

If forced breaks make you resent the app

Some people react badly to being told what to do. If a hard cover on your screen makes you want to uninstall the app within a week, it is the wrong tool for you. A gentler reminder you obey beats a strict one you remove.

Try a softer setup first. Set the break to 5 minutes before you would naturally stand up, pair it with water or a stretch, and keep the reminder small. If you still skip it after two weeks, move to something stricter.

The details

This section is for readers who want the study designs.

Study 1. Talens-Estarelles and colleagues (2023) gave 29 symptomatic computer users webcam-based 20-20-20 reminders for two weeks. Digital eye strain and dry eye symptoms went down while the reminders ran. The improvement did not last one week after the reminders stopped. The study had one group and no control.

Study 2. Johnson and Rosenfield had 30 young adults do a 40-minute word task on a tablet in four sessions. Breaks of 20 seconds came every 5, 10 or 20 minutes, or not at all. Symptoms rose in every session, and scheduled breaks made no significant difference. The authors concluded the evidence does not support 20-second scheduled breaks as a treatment for digital eye strain.

Reading the two together. The benefit in study 1 tracked the reminder, so a disabled or ignored reminder gives nothing. Study 2 found no benefit from the breaks themselves. Whether a 20-second break measurably helps is still disputed.

Skip rules in other apps. LookAway limits skips and snoozes per session and per day. Stretchly allows one postpone per break. ForceBreak adds a wait before the dismiss button appears.

Try EyeHack

EyeHack is a macOS menubar app, $14.99 once, with a 14-day free trial of everything. Every 20 minutes of screen use it covers every connected screen for 20 seconds with no skip and no snooze. Details are on the home page.

Questions

A reminder that arrives mid-task asks you to stop work you are already doing, and one click makes it go away. The cost of skipping is invisible at that moment, so skipping wins.

In one 2023 study of 29 symptomatic computer users, symptoms improved during two weeks of 20-20-20 reminders. A separate 2023 study of 30 young adults found no effect of 20-second breaks on symptoms in a 40-minute tablet task. The evidence is mixed.

EyeHack has no skip and no snooze. Every 20 minutes of screen use it covers every connected screen for 20 seconds, and it waits during calls and screen recording.

EyeHack waits while you're on a call (any app using your microphone or camera) and while a common screen recorder is running. You can also quit it from the menubar at any time.