EyeHackDownload for Mac

Kids, screen time and myopia: what the research says

Updated

TL;DR

  • The best-supported finding is about daylight. In a 2015 trial of 1,903 schoolchildren, 40 extra outdoor minutes a day cut new myopia cases over 3 years from 39.5% to 30.4%.
  • The trial did not measure screen time, so it cannot say that screens cause myopia.
  • Tired, dry eyes after a long session are a different problem from myopia, and the research on 20-second breaks for them is mixed.
  • Only an eye exam can detect myopia. Book one if a child squints, sits very close to screens or complains of blurry vision.

The best-supported finding about children's eyesight is about daylight, and the screen question is still open. In a 2015 trial in China, schools that added a 40-minute outdoor class every day had fewer new cases of myopia after 3 years than schools that did not.

This is not medical advice. See an eye doctor if symptoms persist.

The outdoor time trial

Researchers in Guangzhou compared primary schools. Some added a 40-minute outdoor class to every school day. Others changed nothing.

After 3 years, 30.4% of children in the outdoor schools had developed myopia. In the other schools it was 39.5%. That is 9.1 percentage points fewer.

The takeaway is modest. Outdoor time lowered the rate of new cases. It did not stop myopia, and it changed how fast eyes worsened only slightly.

What this does not tell you about screens

The trial changed outdoor time. It did not measure screen time, so it cannot say that screens cause myopia. Children who spend more hours indoors on tablets also spend fewer hours outside, and the two are hard to separate.

That is why you find confident articles in both directions. A claim that screens damage children's eyes permanently goes beyond the trial. A claim that screens are harmless goes beyond it too.

Tired eyes are a separate issue

Myopia is a change in the shape of the eye over years. Digital eye strain is tired, dry or sore eyes after a long session. They have different causes and different remedies.

For eye strain, the usual advice is the 20-20-20 habit. Every 20 minutes, look at something about 20 feet away for 20 seconds. The research is mixed. One 2023 study of adults found symptoms improved while reminders ran. Another, with young adults reading on a tablet, found little or no effect of 20-second breaks. Neither studied children. Read the full research summary for more.

What to do at home

None of this needs special equipment.

  • Schedule outdoor time every day, in daylight. The trial gave 40 minutes during school hours plus encouragement afterwards.
  • Treat screen breaks as a cheap habit and no myopia treatment. Looking out of a window for 20 seconds costs nothing.
  • Book a regular eye exam. Myopia is diagnosed by measurement, and early detection is the point.
  • Watch for squinting, sitting very close to screens, headaches or complaints about blurry boards at school.

For symptoms after long sessions, see digital eye strain. The roundup of eye break apps for Mac compares reminder apps.

Habits that cost nothing

Parents do not need an app for most of this.

  • Put homework next to a window with daylight, and take a short look outside between tasks.
  • Keep tablets for specific times and not as a default whenever a child is bored.
  • Move the screen so the child is not craning close to it.
  • Make an eye exam part of the school-year routine.

Students and teenagers

Older students who study on a laptop for hours have the same eye strain as office workers. A timer every 20 minutes works the same way for a 16-year-old as for an adult. It builds a habit and is no myopia treatment.

When to book an exam

Myopia has no pain to warn you. A child may say nothing and simply sit closer to the screen. Squinting at the board, rubbing the eyes often and frequent headaches after school work are the usual prompts for a visit. An optometrist can measure the change and advise on glasses or other treatment.

The details

This section is for readers who want the numbers and the limits.

Design. He and colleagues ran a cluster randomized trial in 12 primary schools in Guangzhou, China, published in JAMA in 2015. Six schools (952 students) added a 40-minute outdoor class to every school day and encouraged outdoor activity after school. Six control schools (951 students) changed nothing. In total 1,903 students were followed for 3 years.

Results. 30.4% of eligible children in the intervention schools developed myopia, against 39.5% in the control schools, a difference of 9.1 percentage points. Refraction shifted by -1.42 diopters in the intervention group and -1.59 in the control group, a gap of 0.17 D. The difference in axial length growth (0.95 mm against 0.98 mm) was not statistically significant.

Limits.

  • The trial ran in one Chinese city. Myopia rates and school days differ elsewhere, so the 9.1 point gap is a result for that setting and no forecast for any individual child.
  • It measured new myopia, meaning children who had not yet developed it. It says little about children who already wear glasses. For them the useful step is regular eye exams and an eye doctor's treatment advice.
  • The outdoor classes were part of a structured school program. A child who plays outside on weekends is not in the same condition as one in a daily 40-minute class.

Reading headlines. Three questions sort most of them out.

  1. Was it a trial or a survey? Trials assign the change. Surveys find correlations, and a child who reads for hours may also stay indoors.
  2. What was measured? Myopia, dry eyes and tired eyes at 9 pm are three different outcomes.
  3. How many children, and for how long? The Guangzhou trial followed 1,903 students for 3 years. Many news studies run for weeks.

If an article skips these details, treat it as opinion.

Adult studies of 20-second breaks. One 2023 study of 29 adults found symptoms improved while reminders ran. A 2023 study of 30 young adults reading on a tablet found little or no effect. Neither included children.

Try EyeHack

EyeHack is a macOS menubar app. Every 20 minutes of screen use it covers every connected screen for 20 seconds with no skip button, and one of its break types is real filmed cats that walk onto the screen. It costs $14.99 once with a 14-day free trial, and one EyeHack Pro key covers 3 devices. See the home page or the cat breaks.

Questions

The evidence reviewed here does not settle that. The strongest result is about outdoor time: a randomized trial found that adding 40 outdoor minutes to the school day reduced new myopia cases over 3 years.

Over 3 years, 30.4% of children in the outdoor-class schools developed myopia, against 39.5% in the control schools, a difference of 9.1 percentage points.

There is no trial in children here showing that. Studies of adults are mixed, and breaks are a low-cost habit that is no myopia treatment.

Yes if a child squints, sits very close to screens, or complains of headaches or blurred vision. An eye exam is the only way to detect myopia.